Mikey and Nicky

Peter Falk

Mikey

John Cassavetes

Nicky

Ned Beatty

Kinney

Rose Arrick

Annie

Carol Grace

Nellie

William Hickey

Sid Fine

Sanford Meisner

Dave Resnick

Joyce Van Patten

Jan

M. Emmet Walsh

Bus Driver

Sy Travers

Hotel Clerk

Peter R. Scoppa

Counter Man

Virginia Smith

Jan's Mother

Jean Shevlin

Lady on Bus

Danny Klein

Harry

Martin Wolfson

Candy Store Man

Eugene Hobgood

Mel

David Pendleton

Bar Patron

Will Gill Jr.

Bartender

Marilyn Randall

Shirley

Reuben Greene

Franklyn

Elaine May

Woman on TV (voice) (uncredited)